It’s not about IQ, it’s about EI

Emotional Intelligence is much in demand for leadership posts but is it an overused expression referring to a range of soft skills which are ultimately ignored by recruitment panels/boards in favour of charism and experience?

I don’t like the expression Emotional Intelligence (EI). It makes be feel a bit inadequate. It seems a rather vague reason for rejecting some one for a senior post. I have never been comfortable with IQ tests deciding people’s future on minor differences on a scale that measures what? The ability to do IQ tests? So maybe it’s the fact that EI is so often presented as the other side of the IQ coin that makes me sceptical.

It doesn’t help that references to EI are so overused in the recruitment process and have become a short hand for modern leadership qualities. If what an organisation seeks is to recruit someone who has insight into their own behaviour and how it effects others, someone who excels in building relationships, some one who is mature enough to recognise that dissent and criticism are not evidence of personal disloyalty, then they should say so.

I think the expression has lost meaning and clarity due to over use. Management consultants and recruitment firms drop it into conversation as do HR colleagues as if every one agrees that it’s an essential for a leader. But then the actual recruitment panel revert to classic/old school leadership qualities like charisma, charm, determination and over confidence. Someone who imposes their will through sheer force of personality , some one who takes charge and expects others to fall in line, occasional intimidating, not over concerned with others views and feelings.

Sometimes Emotional Intelligence is referred  to as the softer skills. Which I understand to be a reference to “people skills “ , that is the ability to motivate, to challenge appropriately, to encourage and develop, to be a good listener, to be able to empathise,  to be in tune with those you are responsible for and to be able to speak their language.Which in turn would make someone an effective networker and a skilled negotiator, some one who can gain people’s trust and cooperation. I would consider these skills more relevant than technical skills and harder to gain. I just don’t like referring to them as Emotional Intelligence.

    Read more

    Latest News

    Read More

    Building a wellbeing strategy that supports recruitment and retention

    20 January 2025

    Newsletter

    Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

    Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

    Latest HR Jobs

    University of Oxford – Humanities DivisionSalary: £55,636 to £64,228 (Grade 9)

    If you are interested in this role, please contact Steve Davies, HR Director –. Management of the HR Metrics service providing HR information, analytics and

    Circa £90’000:London Councils:The HR Director & London Regional Employers’ Secretary manages the regional employers’ organisation to ensure it supports London boroughs by sharin.

    Circa £90’000:London Councils:The HR Director & London Regional Employers’ Secretary manages the regional employers’ organisation to ensure it supports London boroughs by sharin.

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE