EAT finds that it was not unfair to dismiss an employee after reopening a previously concluded disciplinary process that had led to a final written warning

In the case of Lyfar-Cissé v Western Sussex University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust Ms Lyfar-Cissé worked as an Associate Director of Transformation at Brighton & Sussex University Hospital NHS Trust. Her role was to further racial equality in the trust, after repeated concerns had been raised about the treatment of BAME staff over several years. This position however was undermined when she told a manager of hers that he was ‘everything she despised in a white manager’.

In the case of Lyfar-Cissé v Western Sussex University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust Ms Lyfar-Cissé worked as an Associate Director of Transformation at Brighton & Sussex University Hospital NHS Trust. Her role was to further racial equality in the trust, after repeated concerns had been raised about the treatment of BAME staff over several years. This position however was undermined when she told a manager of hers that he was ‘everything she despised in a white manager’.

She had also bullied another colleague because of her sexuality and had breached that colleague’s confidentiality by interfering in the grievance process. In January 2017, after a disciplinary hearing, she received a final warning.

Later that year, Western Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust took over the management of the Brighton NHS Trust following a Care Quality Commission (CQC) investigation which concluded that bullying was rife at the trust. Ms Lyfar-Cissé came under new management and questions were asked about her suitability to provide leadership on equality issues. The disciplinary hearing was reopened and Ms Lyfar-Cissé was dismissed. A tribunal rejected her unfair dismissal complaint and she appealed.

The appeal was dismissed.
Ms Lyfar-Cissé argued that re-opening the outcome of the disciplinary proceedings was inequitable and against natural justice as the disciplinary findings against her were all dealt with and addressed; all the parties were bound by the decision to give her a final written warning, and therefore the same matters could not amount to any substantial reason to justify dismissal.

However, the EAT held that the tribunal had not made an error of law. While acknowledging that it is unusual to reopen disciplinary proceedings, the EAT held that the essential question in such a situation is whether the dismissal was fair in all the circumstances (ERA 1996, s 98(4)). There is case law authority to support the argument that the ‘double jeopardy’ rule does not apply to disciplinary proceedings.

The Chief Executive who took over management of the trust told Ms Lyfar-Cissé that she had ‘fatally undermined’ her role by having been found to have acted in the way she did. It was reasonable for the trust to reopen the complaint since the trust was under emergency management in part for its acceptance of poor behaviour. Given the CQC’s findings, Ms Lyfar-Cissé’s refusal to accept any accountability for her actions, and her responsibility for race equality, her dismissal on the grounds of some other substantial reason was fair.

Read more

Latest News

Read More

‘It’s really amazing, what these women have been able to do!’

14 November 2024

Newsletter

Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

Latest HR Jobs

Leeds Arts UniversitySalary: £35,000 to £38,227 per annum This provides summary information and comment on the subject areas covered. Where employment tribunal and appellate court

University Of The Arts LondonSalary: £43,512 per annum This provides summary information and comment on the subject areas covered. Where employment tribunal and appellate court

My client, a growing logistics group, is seeking to hire an experienced and strategic HR Director to lead their Human Resources function. As the HR

Position: Human Resources Director Location: Central London Sector: Restaurants and Leisure Salary: £90k-140k excellent package Our client, a leading operator in the restaurants and leisure

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE