Railway controller wins unfair dismissal claim after train crashes into buffers

In the case of Mr N Smith v Abellio East Anglia Ltd T/a Greater Anglia Nick Smith was dismissed after the shunting of an out of service Greater Anglia train went wrong resulting in it crashing into buffers causing £25,000 damage.
legal challenges

In the case of Mr N Smith v Abellio East Anglia Ltd T/a Greater Anglia Nick Smith was dismissed after the shunting of an out of service Greater Anglia train went wrong resulting in it crashing into buffers causing £25,000 damage.

But an employment tribunal heard radios used to communicate between workers had been faulty at the time.

Static interference meant Mr Smith did not receive a warning of how close the train was to hitting the buffers.

A second worker tasked with communicating the distance was also sacked for failing to implement an emergency stop procedure.

At the time of his dismissal in August 2022 Mr Smith had been employed for 30 years, the last 21 years as yard controller at the Norwich Crown Point Depot servicing trains.

Abellio East Anglia Ltd sacked him after concluding that he was not fully concentrating and that, knowing of the radio problems, he should have been on higher alert.

Mr Smith told the tribunal he’d only had 19 seconds to react to the situation, but during its evidence the company said it had been 30-35 seconds.

As the train was travelling at under 5mph, this was enough time to realise radio transmissions had failed and to stop the train, they added.

However, upholding his claims of unfair and wrongful dismissal, employment judge Louise Brown ruled he had not been grossly negligent.

She said: “I did not find that the claimant’s actions were anywhere near the ‘grave and weighty’ threshold or that he intentionally acted in a way to breach the respondents’ safety policies, and it would be startling if he had chosen to do so especially given the risk to his own safety and that of others on the train.”

She also ruled that him being banned from Greater Anglia premises, not given important documents and not told he could call witnesses to a disciplinary hearing had “created a highly unfair situation”.

A remedy hearing to determine compensation will be held at a later date.

Read more

Latest News

Read More

Addressing alcohol in the workplace – what HR Directors need to know 

25 November 2024

Newsletter

Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

Latest HR Jobs

University of Oxford – Nuffield Department of MedicineSalary: £27,838 to £31,459 per annum (pro rata). This is inclusive of a pensionable Oxford University Weighting of

JOB TITLE: Hotel Manager – FTC 12 months – January 2025 start LOCATION; North West England SALARY: Around £45,000 per year plus performance-based bonus, rewards,

We are seeking a dynamic and driven Human Resources Officer to become a key player in The Welbeck Team In this exciting role, you’ll invent

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE