How to stop generational differences derailing DEI Initiatives

Generations have different views of diversity based on their lived experiences. The five active generations in the workplace have varying expectations for diversity work as a result. Research indicates that traditionalists and baby boomers are less accepting of DEI work, whereas Millennials see it as a “nice to have” and Gen Z, the generation now entering the workforce, sees it as non-negotiable. There is an opportunity to bridge the gap between the different generational groups and how they view DEI. By implementing these three key strategies- Identify, Plan and Measure.

There has been a tug-o-war between the four different generations in the workplace and their views on diversity, equity and inclusion practices, as of late. As millions of Baby Boomers retire each year, the workforce welcomes many more Generation Z workers and their demand for a more inclusive workplace. Research indicates that those of the  Baby Boomer generation view DEI lower on their list of workplace priorities, members of Generation X have mixed views, Millennials recognize its importance, and Generation Z, the most diverse and most-educated American generation yet, believe that workplace equity is imperative. They feel so strongly about inclusive workplace cultures that they rank it above flexibility and compensation as a priority. With this shift in generational leadership in organizations, many leaders wonder, how can I get all generations, with their vastly differing views, invested in creating a more inclusive workplace?

In my 8+ years of experience leading DEI programs, I have observed the generational differences and the complications organizations are faced when they work toward establishing a more inclusive culture. All too often, these obstacles arise when an organization’s approach to DEI caters to only one or two of the generational groups. I have worked with organizations that opt to make DEI mandatory, from a compliance perspective, which inevitably led to backlash from their Baby Boomer and Generation X employees. Other organizations have opted to pursue a bottom-up approach, in which the responsibility to lead the Employee Resource Groups (ERGs) falls solely on the Millenial and Generation Z groups, and more often than not, outside of work hours. These are two approaches that have proven ineffective because there was a failure to understand the different generational groups. Without acknowledging each generational group and how their experiences in the workforce shaped their perspectives, organizations risk further polarizing their employees’ perceptions of DEI.

There is an opportunity to bridge the gap between the different generational groups and how they view DEI. By implementing these three key strategies- Identify, Plan and Measure.

Identify the generational groups in your organization
Understanding the generational groups, their priorities, what energizes them, and how to connect with them in a meaningful way is the first and most important step in bridging the gap. Having insight into the experiences that shaped each generation’s perspectives, will help you understand how to effectively engage them. 

  • Baby Boomers (born 1946-1964): In the aftermath of WWII there was a “boom” in birth-rates, which is how those born during this time came to be known as the Baby Boomers. They are credited with the invention of the modern workplace and witnessed and experienced: the Feminist Movement, the Civil Rights Movement, Recessions, and the Pandemic. They recognize the importance of diversity but are less likely to see a need for inclusion at work. Baby Boomers entered the workforce when the Traditionalists or Silent Generation (now retired) were at the helm when DEI was discussed rarely, if at all, and strong work ethics and loyalty were prioritized. Therefore, they view diversity as a morality and compliance issue, which they tend to focus solely on representation in an organization. They value individualism and were conditioned to see DEI as a personal or political issue that does not belong at work. 
  • Gen X (born 1965-1980): Also called the latch-key or “sandwich” generation, Gen X often grew up in households with divorced or working caregivers, and as a result are very independent.  They are considered the most connected generation having grown up before the advent of the internet, but also mastering the usage of new and advanced technology. This generation was the first to grow up after the Civil Rights movement and received a better education than previous generations. They were exposed to much more diversity in their upbringing, and care about inclusion more as a result. They entered the workforce on the heels of Baby Boomer leadership, and lived through the market crash and recession of 2008, and the pandemic of 2020. They are often overlooked as a generational group, As Gen X assumes more senior leadership roles as millions of Baby Boomers retire, the younger generational groups are looking to them to see what will be their influence on DEI initiatives. 
  • Millennials (born 1981-1996): Millennials are set to comprise 75% of the workforce by 2025. Growing up they were encouraged to take risks, collaborate, and become entrepreneurs in a tech-driven world. Raised by “helicopter” parents, Millenials want clear expectations for DEI and entered the workforce hopeful about inclusion, yet were hesitant to hold organizations accountable for DEI. They recognize that diversity goes beyond representation and that different and unique backgrounds, experiences, views, and styles can create groundbreaking and successful business outcomes. The impact of the recession of 2008, which was around the time many millennials were entering the workforce, shaped their perspectives on work/life balance, loyalty and other workplace priorities that rank higher with the older generations. 
  • Gen Z (born 1997-2013): Born in the peak of US immigration, Gen Z is the most racially and ethnically diverse generation of all time. Given the increased acceptance of LGBTQ+, neurodiversity, and exposure to different racial and ethnic groups, Gen Z has much higher expectations for workplace inclusion. In fact, they demand it. They are looking for employers that reflect and respect their diversity, and for fair treatment of all employees (across gender, race and other diversity dimensions).

When it comes to DEI work, the Baby Boomer and Gen X groups tend to focus solely on the representation of diversity, whereas Millennials and, even more so, Gen Z focus on inclusion and behavior. Millennials respond positively to DEI-focused environments and are 23% more actively engaged when their organizations foster inclusive workplace cultures according to Deloitte. The members of Generation Z view DEI as “non-negotiable” in the workplace, often rating it as the top priority when considering potential employers.

Plan to engage all
It is important to carefully plan how you will engage all employees across different generations. Rather than mandating employees’ participation in DEI initiatives, consider making it a part of the expectations you set forth for all. This language shift may feel subtle, however, it resonates better across different generation groups. Given the high value for individualism in the workplace, and the negative perceptions of mandatory training and compliance, Baby Boomers and Gen Xers can align DEI with their individualist values, and have more freedom of choice on how they participate in DEI. 

I recommend a “choose your own adventure” approach to DEI in which the leadership of the organization emphasizes the importance of participating in DEI initiatives to all employees. Leadership should then encourage all employees to select a way (or better yet, a few ways) to engage that is comfortable and energizing to them personally. This could be in the form of virtual learning programs (private, on-demand), in-person workshops (opportunity to engage with fellow co-workers, build community), leadership team programming (train the leader), and participation in workplace supported groups and activities- book clubs, ERGs, Community Projects, or DEI committees. All activities and learning opportunities should be accessible during work hours as the burden should not be placed on employees outside of work hours. The key is to emphasize that some action and activity is expected as a part of overall performance. It is becoming a common practice for leadership to evaluate an employee’s participation in DEI as a Key Performance Indicator (KPI) in their performance reviews.  It should also be noted that it is important to recognize those who are doing the work, participating, exemplifying allyship and energizing others. Celebrating and acknowledging those who engage will motivate more hesitant employees and create a more supportive environment. 

Measure, track, and adjust
62% of organizations devote little or no resources to DEI, and even fewer measure the impact. To see how impactful DEI is at an organization, it’s critical to measure the data by several key demographics and not just race and gender. Generation is one of the most important demographics and is not to be overlooked when evaluating progress.  When organizations understand the perceptions of DEI across generational groups, they can successfully refine their approach and keep their employees energized and engaged. This cannot be achieved without a baseline of data in the organization and is essential in order to prioritize what you are offering. 

To establish a baseline, here are some questions to consider for measuring DEI in the different generational groups. (Likert Scale)

  • Our organization is committed to DEI.
  • Our workplace is fair for people with diverse backgrounds.
  • I feel seen, heard and feel a sense of belonging at our organization.
  • In the past three months, I have participated in a DEI activity.
  • Our leadership team communicates openly and honestly about DEI.

Consider these questions as a starting point. There are scientifically validated DEI measurement tools that pinpoint specific problems and solutions. Once an organization has a baseline, perceptions can be measured over time, and continuously improved. Rather than a one-size fits all approach, generations can be empowered to participate in DEI in a way that is comfortable and palatable for them, and hopefully, energizes them to continue to progress. 

Organizations that truly understand the varying perceptions of the different generational groups and how to engage them in DEI initiatives, set firm expectations for participation and measure changes in perception over time, are at a competitive advantage. To be relevant to the generation entering the workforce and future customers, organizations must stay committed to DEI long-term, and bring more people into the conversation rather than perpetuating generational polarization. 

    Read more

    Latest News

    Read More

    How to maximize your development efforts

    26 December 2024

    Newsletter

    Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

    Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

    Latest HR Jobs

    A highly successful CPO/People/HR Director that loves to help businesses unlock their potential and drive through people solutions that change lives. If yes, then this

    As the BBC Studios HR Director, you will have responsibility for a global HR team within commercial subsidiaries of the BBC, and lead and foster

    As the BBC Studios HR Director, you will have responsibility for a global HR team within commercial subsidiaries of the BBC, and lead and foster

    Are you an experienced Human Resources Manager? Are you experienced making and supporting strategic business decisions? I want to talk to you I am looking

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

    Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE